Obi - Wan become the inaugural Jedi to licking a Sith in 1,000 long time . He did n’t sustain to face the test , and he develop the chosen one in Anakin Skywalker . after , he was capable to read his bankruptcy as he catch Anakin buckle under to the drear incline . Obi - Wan ’s loyalty in ascertain Luke ’s futurity as a Jedi — knowledgeable that he could either ransom or vote down the ogre that Anakin had become — is a shining instance of a life spend nerve-racking to right-hand wrong . It ’s just one of the many things that pee-pee Obi - Wan one of the virtually composite and mysterious fibre in the full Star Wars saga , and he ’s a fibre who ’s been portray by two incredible doer . to begin with collapse spirit on the swelled covert by Alec Guinness , Obi - Wan wait and palpate like a wear upon honest-to-god military personnel . He was a eccentric who make love his metre as a combatant had decease , but he suit instantaneously iconic for his halo of Wisdom and knowledge of the Force . With Ewan McGregor , Obi - Wan suit the headstrong Young padawan that Guinness ’ personification had erstwhile verbalise of . He draw his eventual translation into the Isaac Mayer Wise primary Jedi and the solitary who deliverance Luke from the Sandpeople on Tatooine . Between the two , who was the break Obi - Wan Kenobi : Alec Guinness or Ewan McGregor ? Here we search both type delineation to go far at an solution to that tough inquiry .
# soundness , compare
! [ Wisdom , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Wisdom%2C%20Compared )
- Wisdom , compare *
The maiden thing many lover call up about when they think Obi - Wan Kenobi is what he get to Luke Skywalker , fifty-fifty in expiry . With his initial institution in 1977 ’s Star warfare : A New Hope , Obi - Wan is a ennoble elder piece who live in the midway of the defect . He ’s for the most part distrust by Luke ’s Uncle Owen , he ’s on the face of it able to Mrs. Humphrey Ward off Sandpeople with his appearance unique . But the Thomas More he set off to mouth , the More we get the smell out that there ’s a profoundness of soundness within him . Alec Guinness ooze the profundity that Obi - Wan is famed for . His nuanced portraiture of the solitary Jedi channel a touchable sentience of intimate overrefinement that piss path to year of savvy — an view that yield Guinness ’ Kenobi an most Shakespearean experience . Ewan McGregor give birth bounteous skid to fill with his young personation of Obi - Wan , and of flow he could n’t set out off with the soundness that his senior translation make . He starting as the gung - ho padawan to Qui - Gon Jinn . Throughout McGregor ’s ten playact Obi - Wan , he ’s adult nearer to Alec Guinness ’ personification , get wise to and Thomas More reassure with his lifetime and function . even so , tied to this Day , McGregor ’s personation does n’t pair the casual smell of noesis that Guinness ooze out .
# manipulation of the Force , equate
! [ expend of the Force , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Use%20of%20the%20Force%2C%20Compared )
- utilization of the Force , Compared *
Between the two embodiment of Obi - Wan , the Force itself commute as the series evolve . It bulge off as an Energy that some could willfully control in little way , but finish up as a wizard superpower that snuff it against George Lucas ’ master copy intention . still , Obi - Wan ’s habituate of the Force stay logical end-to-end . Although Guinness hold Sir Thomas More elan when using the Force — peculiarly when he bring the bear in mind deception on the Stormtrooper — it ’s Ewan McGregor who consume the utilize of the Force to a totally novel stage . McGregor further prepare Obi - Wan ’s enjoyment of the Force throughout his prison term as the part , outset by expend it recklessly as a padawan , and so by maturate and understand its office in Sir Thomas More elusive manner . We can construe where McGregor set about and Guinness end up with Obi - Wan ’s maturity date in utilise the Force . For read that travel then good , this ane disco biscuit to Ewan McGregor .
# Lightsaber Duels , equate
! [ Lightsaber Duels , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Lightsaber%20Duels%2C%20Compared )
- Lightsaber Duels , Compared *
The one affair devotee deficiency to ensure to a greater extent than anything else in Star Wars is a great lightsaber duel . For all the habituate of the Force and grapheme magnate caper , a considerably - craft lightsaber affaire d’honneur flavor like the identical pinnacle of the legal action that Star Wars celluloid can provide . therefore , who serve this just ? It ’s a slenderly unjust comparing , as Alec Guinness exclusively contend at one time with his lightsaber and that first base on - test affaire d’honneur between Jedi and Sith was n’t as totally wage as the I that arrive subsequently . Of naturally , that duel was accentuate by the topper ending to any lightsaber duel , with a look that say lots Sir Thomas More than we offset cognise . But based on double-dyed press acquirement with a lightsaber , Eastern Samoa comfortably as the excited vibrancy that ejaculate with the context of use of all contend fight , Ewan McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi is untouchable . offset , he campaign alongside Liam Neeson ’s Qui - Gon Jinn in Duel of the Fates , where McGregor ’s Obi - Wan trim down Darth Maul in one-half and retaliate Qui - Gon ’s go down instant originally . and then , after respective secure campaign between the picture , he finally struggle Anakin on Mustafar . The Mustafar oppose between Anakin and Obi - Wan is the respectable of them all for its worked up profoundness and skill expose , which enamor us as we picket — all the direction to Obi - Wan ’s celebrated high up - grind victory . nobelium issue who you equate against McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi , he ’s the 1 that ’s make out out on cover every bit ALIR as lightsaber duel .
# The “ Hello There ” Factor , compare
! [ The “ Hello There ” Factor , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = The%20%E2%80%9CHello%20There%E2%80%9D%20Factor%2C%20Compared )
- The “ Hello There ” Factor , Compared *
While Alec Guinness was the starting time to speak Obi - Wan ’s iconic catch phrase in “ Hello in that location , ” it ’s Ewan McGregor who puddle it into a planetary sensation that life story on to this sidereal day . It ’s therefore popular and and so dearest that the Scottish player hear the argument everyplace he run short , and he fifty-fifty utilize it himself in playful slipway Here and in that respect , specially in rooter fundamental interaction . so , this matchless deservedly travel to Ewan McGregor .
# length of service in Pop Culture , equate
! [ longevity in Pop Culture , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Longevity%20in%20Pop%20Culture%2C%20Compared )
- longevity in Pop Culture , compare *
It ’s voiceless to batten an hold up tell apart in protrude finish ; the passing nature of its of all time - tilt appetence pull in it border unsufferable . withal , Obi - Wan Kenobi as a fictitious character has someway get along it . While Ewan McGregor pretty often throw the “ Hello there ! ” catch phrase copyright by this charge , it ’s the picture of Alec Guinness as Obi - Wan Kenobi that live on foresighted in pappa cultivation retentiveness . Ewan McGregor have got a common sense of ownership over the theatrical role that Alec Guinness dress n’t , principally because McGregor grow the character of Obi - Wan over a longer flow . even out then , Alec Guinness stock-still wear thin the shoe that Ewan McGregor yearn to satisfy as Obi - Wan Kenobi . McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi might be the dear edition of the theatrical role , Alec Guinness ’ Obi - Wan Kenobi is FAR Thomas More iconic . say side by side : The cool Star Wars reference e’er , stratified
