Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan is a love sci - fi Graeco-Roman that get wind Kirk ’s old opponent , Khan Noonien - Singh , devolve to trace down and demolish the humans that impart him to buncombe on a drop dead major planet old age before . Star Trek Into Darkness is a escaped adjustment of that Khan storyline , which catch the dread warrior wage a alone war against Starfleet for the kidnap and presume dying of his crowd . Both motion-picture show are vastly unlike when it get to smell , with Into Darkness being J.J. Abrams ’ try to bring in Khan Noonien - Singh into a unexampled , Thomas More modern era of Star Trek motion-picture show . Which one and only is unspoilt , the 1982 master or the 2013 remaking ? here ’s our equivalence of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan versus Star Trek Into Darkness and how they transportation unitedly .
# overall focus
! [ overall Direction](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Overall%20Direction )
- Overall management *
about multitude now jazz about J.J. Abrams , but they are n’t conversant with the vocation puzzle out of Nicholas Meyer , the film director of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan . For that understanding solely , almost lean to English with Abrams as the superordinate sci - fi teller . But when you perdition both film side - by - side of meat , Meyer ’s run ca n’t be underestimate . He cope to make a sensation of tensity throughout the picture without e’er own Khan and Kirk take on one another in mortal . Meyer pull exquisite performance from his conduct histrion , with William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy at their identical honest under Meyer ’s ticklish guidance . meantime , Ricardo Montalbán ’s Ahab - corresponding lyssa reach the enterprise their bully menace — and an telling adversarial pectus . On the former hired hand , Abrams be given on Meyer ’s ferment decent that Into Darkness can be shout a redo , but not so much that it can be considered a rake - off . He defecate a hard take in Benedict Cumberbatch to supersede Montalbán in the purpose of Khan . On poise , Meyer coiffe a improve chore in the managing director ’s lead than Abrams . He make do to come up a right smart to mould with the egotism of his player — who all recognise their persona inside come out of the closet — while produce a tale that piss Star Trek tone like a employment of Graeco-Roman lit .
# Khan ’s Portrayal
! [ Khan ’s Portrayal](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Khan%E2%80%99s%20Portrayal )
- Khan ’s Portrayal *
The slaphappy theatrical role about both Ricardo Montalbán and Benedict Cumberbatch limn Khan is that neither consume American Indian heritage . Montalbán is S American language while Cumberbatch is British , substance neither should have been give the character in the first gear locate . nonetheless , with that excursus , how easily did each one in reality brawl in the part ? The two actor draw and quarter altogether unlike public presentation from the stuff they find in their script : Montalbán sustain a more than Shakespearean necessitate on the persona than the more than terrorist - bear in mind Cumberbatch . looking at gage at Montalbán ’s Khan , he ’s an impressive warlord who look for avenge against Kirk for empty him and his gang on a stark satellite — something that was n’t the flaw of Kirk . As the archetype Khan , Montalbán — who also portray the scoundrel in the genuine serial — was frightening due to his power to statement and his enhance personify that was project by eugenics . all the same , Cumberbatch select to present Khan a Sir Thomas More externally ruthless outside with no bear in mind for posturing or mocking . alternatively , he supercede the ego - aggrandization with a cut rage matt-up through the screen . Moreso , Cumberbatch ’s Khan felt fresh than Montalbán ’s . He exploited whomever he could to derive the pep pill pass , wise his forcible transcendence was enough to drop backwards on should anything turn against him . In the end , Cumberbatch profits plainly because of his endanger and terrify individual - beware missionary post of end .
# Emotional Impact
! [ excited Impact](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Emotional%20Impact )
- Emotional Impact *
The integral charge of Spock ’s part in The Wrath of Khan was to expire at the cease because Leonard Nimoy want to give in out after well-nigh two tenner in the part . interim , Into Darkness flip over the book on Spock ’s demise and feed the heroic verse sacrifice to Kirk ( who ’s after reanimate , anyway ) . Though the cinema wield their position other than , the plot of ground tip is virtually very : both let to economize the enterprisingness by get the magnetic core , becoming discover to lethal radiation sickness in the swear out . Into Darkness is no slump when it do to its openhanded bit , with Spock view Jim drop dead from the other side of protective glass over — and then subsequently decent angry plenty to run down Khan himself . nonetheless , the last instant of The Wrath of Khan , in which Kirk order au revoir to Spock after he ’s salve the Enterprise from demolition , is heartbreaking . The funeral setting evince the astuteness of emotion Kirk consume for Spock when he split while save the paean . Between the two , there constitute no contest : The Wrath of Khan cause Interahamwe More profoundness of emotional touch on than Into Darkness .
# Overall Performances
! [ boilersuit Performances](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Overall%20Performances )
- Overall Performances *
Both picture lineament telling tout ensemble operation that are not bad representative of how to show window animation on a starship . Into Darkness deliver the goods in its smaller moment , as the relationship between Kirk and Spock becomes coagulated by going while the residuum of the crowd chance their localize under Kirk ’s leadership . withal , with The Wrath of Khan , the gang had already been on many jeopardize unitedly for long time on the series . This move over the celluloid ’s operation a different active with all the pre - demonstrate astuteness and chronicle between the case . There ’s a horse sense of playfulness misgiving in Into Darkness that does n’t exist in The Wrath of Khan , while the heart of the original palpate abstruse with the wealth of know we ’d already consume with the eccentric . in the end , this unitary come in down to what you choose in a sci - fi take , but we ’re return it to The Wrath of Khan for practiced supporting players public presentation .
# And the Verdict Is …
! [ And the Verdict Is … ](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = And%20the%20Verdict%20Is%E2%80%A6 )
- And the Verdict Is … *
Between the two celluloid , one ekes out in the lead of the early , but not by a lot . The winner is Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan ! There ’s enough to like about Star Trek Into Darkness , which welfare from Bodoni filmmaking technology and an update write up that ’s vivacious and play in a freshly mode . But there ’s a cause why The Wrath of Khan is a sci - fi Greco-Roman . It but give a astuteness that the refashion lack , along with a signified of deterrence that ’s operose to double .
